rhome
How It WorksPricingFor AgentsAbout
Back to Learning Center
Affordable Homeownership

How Insurance Costs Are Changing in High-Risk Markets and What Co-Buyers Should Do

Insurers are pulling out of Florida, California, and Louisiana, leaving homebuyers with expensive last-resort coverage and higher monthly costs. Here is how to navigate rising insurance costs as a co-buyer and what to do before making an offer.

Rhome Editorial
7 min read
Ready to Buy
How Insurance Costs Are Changing in High-Risk Markets and What Co-Buyers Should Do

Buying a home has always required budgeting for insurance. But in a growing
number of markets across the United States, homeowners insurance has shifted
from a manageable line item to one of the most consequential costs in the
entire purchase decision. In states like Florida, California, and Louisiana,
the private insurance market has contracted sharply. Carriers that once
competed for customers are now exiting these states entirely, leaving buyers
with fewer options, higher premiums, and in some cases coverage gaps that
require multiple policies to fill.

For co-buyers, this is not a reason to stop looking. But it is a reason to
understand what is happening, do the research before making an offer, and
budget accurately for what insurance will actually cost. Here is what every
co-buyer needs to know.

What Is Happening to Insurance Costs

Homeowners insurance is priced on risk. Insurers collect premiums, pay out
claims, and invest the float. When claims consistently exceed what premiums
cover, insurers either raise rates or stop writing policies in that market.

Over the past several years, climate-related events have pushed claims costs
far above what actuarial models historically predicted. Hurricanes are
hitting with greater intensity. Wildfires are burning through communities
that were once considered low-risk. Flooding is affecting areas well outside
designated flood zones. Reinsurers, the companies that insure the insurers,
have raised their own prices dramatically in response. Those costs flow
downstream to homeowners.

The result is a market that looks very different from five years ago.
Several major national carriers have either stopped writing new policies in
high-risk states, reduced coverage in specific counties, or exited those
markets entirely. This is not a temporary dip. It reflects a structural
reassessment of where private insurance can profitably operate.

For buyers in affected markets, the practical effects are straightforward:
premiums are higher, coverage options are narrower, and in some areas the
only available policy comes from a state-backed insurer of last resort.

Florida: Citizens Insurance and the Shrinking Private Market

Florida is the clearest example of what happens when a private insurance
market faces sustained pressure. The state has long been exposed to
hurricane risk, but the back-to-back hurricane seasons of 2017, 2018, 2022,
and 2024, combined with years of insurance litigation that inflated claims
costs, pushed carriers to the breaking point.

Over a dozen insurers became insolvent or withdrew from Florida between 2020
and 2023. Companies that remained raised rates aggressively. In some coastal
counties, annual premiums that once cost $2,000 to $3,000 reached $8,000,
$12,000, or more for standard homes. Some buyers in high-risk zip codes
discovered they could not find a private policy at any price.

The fallback is Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, Florida's
state-backed insurer of last resort. Citizens was created to provide
coverage when the private market cannot or will not. At its peak in 2023,
Citizens had grown to cover more than 1.4 million policies, far beyond its
intended scope. The state has since pushed a depopulation program, shifting
policies back to private carriers where possible. For buyers today, Citizens
remains an option but not always the easiest path: policies have coverage
limits, Citizens requires separate flood insurance in many areas, and the
state has periodically raised Citizens' own rates to reduce its competitive
advantage over private carriers.

Flood insurance is its own separate requirement in Florida. Many coastal and
inland properties sit in FEMA Special Flood Hazard Areas, which require
lenders to mandate flood coverage. That coverage comes through the National
Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or, increasingly, private flood carriers.
Both add to total annual insurance costs.

Co-buyers in Florida should budget for two or three policies rather than
one: a standard homeowners policy (private or Citizens), a separate flood
policy if in a flood zone, and in some cases a separate wind policy if the
homeowners policy excludes wind damage in coastal areas.

California: FAIR Plan and the Exit of Major Carriers

California's insurance challenge is driven by wildfire. After catastrophic
fire seasons in 2017, 2018, 2020, and 2021, several major national carriers
announced they would stop writing new homeowners policies in California or
pull back significantly from high-risk counties. State Farm, Allstate, and
Farmers all made significant changes to their California operations between
2022 and 2024.

The California FAIR Plan is the state's insurer of last resort, similar in
function to Florida's Citizens. Coverage through the FAIR Plan is basic: it
covers fire, wind, hail, and explosion, but does not include liability
coverage or many of the protections included in a standard homeowners
policy. Buyers who rely on the FAIR Plan typically need to purchase a
separate "Difference in Conditions" (DIC) policy to fill coverage gaps,
which adds cost and complexity.

California regulators have also been working through a significant reform
effort. For years, Proposition 103 limited how insurers could price risk by
restricting the use of forward-looking catastrophe models. Carriers argued
they could not price California policies in a way that reflected actual
risk, which contributed to their withdrawal. The state's Department of
Insurance has been working to implement new rules that would allow more
actuarially accurate pricing in exchange for carriers returning to the
market. These changes are ongoing, and the market remains in transition.

For co-buyers in California, the key variable is zip code. Properties in
high wildfire risk zones, particularly in foothill communities, parts of the
Wine Country, portions of Los Angeles County, and many rural areas, carry
far greater insurance challenges than properties in lower-risk
neighborhoods. Before making an offer on any California property, check the
state's fire hazard severity zone maps and get an insurance quote specific
to that address.

Louisiana: Repeated Losses and Cascading Rate Increases

Louisiana has faced its own insurance market contraction, driven largely by
hurricane exposure. Hurricanes Laura, Delta, Ida, and Zeta struck Louisiana
in a compressed period between 2020 and 2021, generating enormous insured
losses. In the aftermath, more than a dozen insurers became insolvent or
left the Louisiana market.

Louisiana Citizens Property Insurance, the state's insurer of last resort,
absorbed a large share of displaced policyholders. Rates in many parishes
climbed steeply. In some areas of coastal Louisiana, premiums more than
doubled in the space of two or three years. The challenge for buyers is that
Louisiana's insurance market recovery has been slow: fewer private carriers
have returned compared to markets that experienced single catastrophic
events.

Buyers considering Louisiana properties, particularly in coastal parishes
and areas prone to flooding from storm surge, should budget conservatively
for insurance and investigate current market availability early in the home
search, not at the end of it.

How Rising Insurance Affects Monthly Co-Ownership Costs

Insurance is a real component of monthly housing cost, and in high-risk
markets it has become large enough to materially affect affordability
calculations.

Consider a $450,000 home purchased by three co-buyers using FHA financing.
At a 6.75% interest rate with 3.5% down, the principal and interest payment
is roughly $2,790 per month for the group, or about $930 per person. In a
market with average insurance costs of $2,400 per year, insurance adds about
$200 per month to the group's total bill, or roughly $67 per person.

Now consider the same home in a high-risk Florida coastal county where
insurance costs $9,600 per year plus $3,600 for a separate flood policy.
Combined insurance runs $1,100 per month for the group, or about $367 per
person. The insurance alone adds more than 39% to each person's monthly
housing cost relative to a normal market.

This is not a reason to avoid high-risk markets categorically. But it is a
reason to include insurance in every affordability calculation from the
start. The price on a listing does not tell you what the home will cost to
own. Insurance costs, property taxes, HOA fees, and reserves all affect the
real number.

Because co-buyers split these costs by ownership percentage, the per-person
burden is lower than it would be for a solo buyer. But the costs still
accumulate, and they need to fit within each person's budget.

How to Research Insurance Costs Before Making an Offer

Insurance costs vary significantly by address, not just by city or zip code.
A home on one block may be insurable by three private carriers at
competitive rates. A home two blocks away, closer to the coast or within a
wildfire severity zone, may be insurable only through the state plan at
twice the price. Do not assume.

Here is how to research insurance before you make an offer:

Get a quote at the address, not the region. Contact two or three
independent insurance brokers and ask for quotes tied to the specific
property address. Independent brokers can shop across multiple carriers,
which gives you a clearer picture of market availability and pricing than
going directly to a single insurer.

Check flood zone status. The FEMA Flood Map Service Center allows anyone
to look up a property's flood zone designation. Properties in Special Flood
Hazard Areas (labeled Zone A or Zone V on FEMA maps) require flood insurance
for federally backed mortgages, including FHA loans. This is a separate
policy with a separate premium.

Check wildfire risk ratings in California. California's Department of
Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) publishes fire hazard severity zone
maps. Properties in Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones face the steepest
insurance challenges. Buyers can also use third-party risk tools that
provide property-level wildfire risk scores.

Ask the seller for current insurance costs. Sellers in high-risk markets
are required to disclose known material facts about the property. The
current insurance cost is not always required disclosure, but many sellers
will provide it if asked. Use it as a starting point, not a guarantee, since
your policy will be priced separately.

Factor in all required policies. In some markets you may need a
homeowners policy, a separate flood policy, and a separate wind or fire
policy. Price all of them before you decide whether the home fits your
budget.

Insurance Requirements in High-Risk Markets

FHA loans require hazard insurance on the property being purchased. In flood
zones, they also require flood insurance. This is not optional: lenders will
not close a loan without proof of required coverage in place.

Beyond lender requirements, there are practical coverage considerations for
co-buyers in high-risk markets:

Liability coverage. Standard homeowners policies include personal
liability coverage. If a guest is injured on the property, or if the
property damages a neighbor's home, liability coverage pays for legal
defense and settlements. This is especially important in a co-ownership
arrangement where multiple people share legal responsibility for the
property.

Loss of use coverage. If the home becomes uninhabitable due to a covered
event, loss of use coverage pays for temporary housing. For co-buyers who
depend on the home as their primary residence, this matters.

Coverage for the ownership entity. Because Rhome co-ownership groups hold title
through an ownership entity, insurance policies need to name the entity as the insured. Most
insurers who write residential policies are familiar with this structure,
but verify it explicitly when getting quotes. Some carriers write a landlord
or commercial policy for entity-owned properties rather than a standard HO-3
homeowners policy. An experienced broker can help you find the right
product.

FAIR Plan and DIC policies in California. If you end up on the
California FAIR Plan, you will need a separate Difference in Conditions
policy to get liability coverage, theft coverage, water damage coverage, and
other protections the FAIR Plan excludes. Price both policies together.

How the Repair Reserve Buffers Insurance Gaps

Every Rhome co-ownership group maintains a shared repair reserve, funded by
monthly contributions from all co-owners. This account exists to cover
maintenance, repairs, and unexpected property expenses that arise between
insured events.

In high-risk markets, the repair reserve plays an additional role: it
provides a buffer for costs that insurance does not cover.

Insurance policies have deductibles. In hurricane-prone areas, many policies
carry separate hurricane or wind deductibles that are expressed as a
percentage of the home's insured value rather than a flat dollar amount. A
2% hurricane deductible on a home insured for $400,000 means the group pays
the first $8,000 of any hurricane claim out of pocket. A healthy repair
reserve means that money is available without anyone scrambling.

Policies also have exclusions. Standard homeowners policies do not cover
flooding, sewer backup, or mold in many cases. If your property experiences
damage from an event that falls outside your policy, the repair reserve
provides a financial cushion while the group decides how to respond.

The repair reserve is not a substitute for comprehensive insurance. But it
works alongside insurance to ensure the group can handle costs that arise
even when coverage applies, because deductibles, co-pays, and uncovered
expenses are part of real-world insurance use.

When High Insurance Costs Should Change Your Buying Decision

Insurance costs are a legitimate factor in deciding whether to buy a
specific property. In some cases, they should change the decision.

The clearest signal is when insurance brings your all-in monthly cost above
what your budget can support. If the mortgage fits your share of the payment
but insurance, taxes, and reserves push your total monthly housing cost
beyond 35% to 40% of your gross income, the property may not be affordable
even if the purchase price looks manageable.

A second signal is when insurance is available only through the state plan
with meaningful coverage gaps. If you can only get FAIR Plan coverage in
California and the DIC policy to supplement it is hard to obtain or very
expensive, you should understand exactly what you are and are not covered
for. Some high-risk properties carry residual risk that even layered
policies do not fully address.

A third signal is when the property has a claims history that makes it
harder to insure. Sellers must disclose insurance claims filed on the
property in most states. A property with multiple recent claims,
particularly water damage or fire claims, may face difficulty obtaining
coverage or may be offered coverage only at elevated rates.

None of these signals are automatic disqualifiers. Co-buying distributes
these costs across multiple people, which makes the math work in some cases
where solo buying would not. But they are worth examining carefully, with
real numbers, before committing to a specific property.

The most important step you can take is to get insurance quotes before you
finalize your offer. In high-risk markets, that number belongs in your
budget from day one, not as an afterthought after you are already under
contract.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does co-ownership change how homeowners insurance works?

Yes, in an important way. Because Rhome structures co-ownership through an ownership entity, the entity is typically the named insured on the policy rather than individual owners. This means the group needs a policy that covers an entity-owned primary residence, which is a standard product but one that requires a broker who understands the structure. All co-owners are protected under the same policy, and coverage costs are shared proportionally just like the mortgage.

Can we still get a mortgage if we can only get coverage through a FAIR plan or Citizens Insurance?

Generally yes. Lenders require proof of hazard insurance, not proof of private market insurance. Citizens Insurance in Florida and the California FAIR Plan are both state-backed options that satisfy lender requirements. Wind and flood coverage may need to be purchased separately as endorsements or standalone policies, so confirm with your lender exactly what combined coverage they need to see before closing.

How do we split insurance costs among co-owners?

Insurance premiums are a shared operating expense paid from the group's shared account, split according to each co-owner's ownership percentage. If three co-owners each hold one-third of the property, each contributes one-third of the annual premium. The Rhome platform tracks these contributions automatically so there is never ambiguity about who owes what.

What happens if our insurer drops us after we buy?

Non-renewal is a real risk in high-risk markets. If your insurer sends a non-renewal notice, you typically have 45 to 90 days to find replacement coverage. The group should act immediately: contact a local independent broker, explore the state insurer of last resort (Citizens in Florida, the FAIR Plan in California), and check whether any national carriers are still writing in your area. Your co-ownership governance agreement should specify that all owners are notified if any insurance issue arises, so no one is caught off guard.

Is high insurance a reason not to co-buy in a specific market?

It can be. Insurance is a carrying cost that affects your real monthly payment just as much as the mortgage does. If insurance adds $600 or more per month to a property's expenses, that cost needs to be factored into your affordability calculation before you make an offer. In some cases, a less expensive home in a lower-risk zip code may produce a lower all-in monthly cost than a more attractive home in a flood zone or wildfire corridor. Co-buyers should get insurance quotes as part of their due diligence, not after going under contract.