When multiple people share ownership of a primary residence, repairs and maintenance become a shared operational responsibility, not just a practical one. The good news: the structure already exists to handle this cleanly. An Governance Agreement, paired with a funded repair reserve, gives co-owners a clear decision-making framework for routine upkeep, unexpected repairs, and major capital improvements. Most co-ownership disputes around maintenance happen not because the situation is inherently difficult, but because the rules were never written down.
This article breaks down how to handle every category of maintenance and repair in a co-owned home, from who calls the plumber to how co-owners vote on a new roof.
Why Repairs and Maintenance Are a Shared Responsibility
In a co-owned home structured under an ownership structure, all owners hold an interest in the same property. That means the physical condition of the property affects everyone's equity, living experience, and long-term investment. A leaking roof that one co-owner wants to ignore and another wants to fix immediately is no longer a personal preference issue. It becomes a property management decision with financial and legal dimensions.
This shared stake is why the co-ownership legal structure must address maintenance explicitly. Leaving it to informal agreement or assumed goodwill is one of the most common mistakes new co-owners make. When a repair comes up, people who have different financial situations, different standards for urgency, and different definitions of "necessary" will find themselves in conflict unless the Governance Agreement has already settled the rules.
The three core elements that resolve this are:
- A written Governance Agreement that defines categories of decisions and who has authority to make them
- A funded repair reserve that provides immediate liquidity for repairs without requiring co-owners to agree on the spot about money
- A clear decision threshold for routine repairs versus capital improvements
The Difference Between Routine Maintenance, Repairs, and Capital Improvements
Not every property expense is the same, and the appropriate decision process depends on what kind of expense you are dealing with. Co-owners should agree on clear definitions before any issue arises.
Routine Maintenance
Routine maintenance is the ongoing, predictable upkeep required to keep the property in its current condition. This includes:
- HVAC filter replacements and seasonal servicing
- Gutter cleaning
- Lawn and landscaping maintenance
- Pest control
- Smoke and carbon monoxide detector battery replacement
- Minor caulking and weatherstripping
These tasks are typically low-cost and recur on a schedule. The Governance Agreement should designate who is responsible for scheduling and overseeing routine maintenance, whether that is one co-owner, a rotating responsibility, or a property manager. Costs come from the repair reserve or are split per ownership percentage without requiring a formal vote.
Repairs
Repairs address something that has broken down or stopped functioning correctly. A burst pipe, a failed water heater, a broken HVAC unit, or a damaged window are all repairs. The defining characteristic of a repair is that it restores the property to a prior functioning state, it does not improve or upgrade it.
Repairs vary widely in cost. A clogged drain is a $150 repair. A foundation crack is a $20,000 repair. The Governance Agreement should establish a cost threshold that determines whether a repair can be authorized by one co-owner or requires group approval.
A common structure:
- Below $1,000: Any single co-owner can authorize and initiate
- $1,000 to $5,000: Requires notification to all co-owners and majority approval
- Above $5,000: Requires a formal vote with a defined majority (often two-thirds or unanimous)
These thresholds are examples. Your group should set figures that reflect your property's value, your comfort level, and your ownership structure.
Capital Improvements
Capital improvements go beyond restoring the property to its prior condition. They add value, extend the property's useful life, or significantly change the nature of a space. Examples include:
- Replacing a functional kitchen with a higher-end renovation
- Adding a deck, bathroom, or finished basement
- Installing solar panels
- Upgrading from a standard HVAC to a zoned smart system
- Replacing single-pane windows with triple-pane throughout the home
Capital improvements require a higher decision threshold because they involve larger spending and often change the equity value of the property for all owners. They should always require a formal co-owner vote, and the vote threshold should be clearly defined in the co-ownership agreement.
How the Repair Reserve Fund Works
The repair reserve is a shared fund that co-owners contribute to on an ongoing basis, separate from the mortgage and other shared carrying costs. It exists specifically to cover maintenance, repairs, and agreed-upon improvements without requiring co-owners to scramble for money each time something breaks.
Contributions
Each co-owner contributes to the repair reserve in proportion to their ownership share. If three co-owners each hold one-third of the ownership structure, each contributes one-third of the monthly reserve amount. The total monthly contribution is typically calculated as a percentage of the property's value, commonly 1% to 1.5% of the property value annually, divided into monthly deposits.
For a $600,000 home, a 1% annual reserve target equals $6,000 per year or $500 per month, split among co-owners by ownership share.
The Governance Agreement should specify:
- The monthly contribution amount for each co-owner
- The target reserve balance (often equivalent to 3 to 6 months of the annual reserve goal)
- The bank account structure (typically a dedicated ownership structure account)
- Who has signatory authority for reserve disbursements
Withdrawals
Withdrawals from the repair reserve should follow the same cost thresholds that govern repair decisions. Small withdrawals for routine maintenance or minor repairs can often be made by a designated managing co-owner. Larger withdrawals should require documented approval from the co-owner group, consistent with the decision thresholds described above.
All withdrawals should be tracked with receipts and a simple ledger so every co-owner can see how reserve funds are being used. Transparency here prevents disputes later.
Replenishment
When the reserve is drawn down, co-owners replenish it according to their ownership share. If the reserve falls below a minimum balance defined in the Governance Agreement, co-owners may be required to make a one-time catch-up contribution. The Governance Agreement should define what happens when a co-owner cannot or refuses to contribute to replenishment, including any remedies available to the group.
Decision-Making for Ordinary Repairs
Ordinary repairs are the most frequent category and should have the lowest friction for authorization. Requiring four co-owners to convene a formal meeting every time a faucet needs replacing will create bottlenecks and frustration.
A well-designed Governance Agreement creates a tiered system:
Designated Managing Co-Owner: One co-owner can be designated as the primary point of contact for property operations. This person is authorized to initiate and oversee repairs below the low-cost threshold, hire vetted vendors, and ensure work is completed. This role can rotate annually or remain fixed, per the group's preference.
Notification Protocol: For repairs above the low-cost threshold but below the formal vote threshold, the managing co-owner must notify all other co-owners within a defined time window (often 24 to 48 hours) and receive no objection before proceeding. This preserves speed while keeping everyone informed.
Vendor Relationships: Co-owners benefit from establishing relationships with preferred vendors for common services, plumbers, electricians, HVAC technicians, and general contractors, before those services are urgently needed. The Governance Agreement can require that licensed, insured vendors be used for any repair above a minimum dollar amount.
Cost Allocation: All ordinary repair costs are paid from the repair reserve or split by ownership percentage, as specified in the Governance Agreement. Individual co-owners should not be expected to front costs unilaterally and seek reimbursement, except in emergency situations addressed below.
Decision-Making for Capital Improvements
Capital improvements carry more weight because they change the property and its value, and they involve meaningful spending. The decision process should be more deliberate.
Proposal and Discussion
Any co-owner can propose a capital improvement. The proposal should include a scope of work, at least two contractor bids, the projected cost, and the anticipated benefit to the property. This gives the group a concrete basis for discussion rather than a vague idea.
Vote Threshold
The Governance Agreement should specify the vote required to approve capital improvements. Common options:
- Simple majority by ownership share: More than 50% of ownership interest votes yes
- Supermajority: Two-thirds or three-quarters of ownership interest votes yes
- Unanimous: All co-owners must approve
For improvements above a high cost threshold, unanimous consent is common. For mid-range improvements that a reasonable person would recognize as value-additive, a supermajority may be sufficient. The right threshold depends on your group's philosophy and the nature of your ownership stakes.
Cost Allocation
Capital improvement costs are typically allocated by ownership percentage. A co-owner holding 40% of the ownership structure pays 40% of the approved improvement cost. This allocation can be drawn from the repair reserve if sufficient funds are available, or co-owners contribute the required amounts directly.
The Governance Agreement should address what happens if one co-owner cannot pay their share of an approved capital improvement. Options include allowing the other co-owners to front the cost (creating an internal debt obligation owed by the non-contributing co-owner), or allowing the improvement to proceed only with modified scope, or delaying the improvement until all co-owners can fund their share.
Ownership Adjustment for Improvements
In some co-ownership arrangements, co-owners agree that if one party funds a disproportionate share of a significant capital improvement, the ownership structure's ownership percentages can be adjusted to reflect the added contribution. This is a complex provision that requires careful drafting and should involve a real estate attorney. If your group is considering this structure, it must be written into the Governance Agreement before any improvement is made, not negotiated after the fact.
What Happens When Co-Owners Disagree on a Repair
Disagreements will happen. The goal of a good Governance Agreement is not to eliminate disagreement but to give it a structured resolution process.
For repairs below the authorization threshold: The managing co-owner has authority to proceed. A dissenting co-owner who objects to the vendor choice or scope does not have the right to block a below-threshold repair.
For repairs requiring majority approval: If a vote fails, the repair is not authorized. If the dissenters believe this creates a safety hazard or unreasonable property damage risk, the Governance Agreement should provide an escalation path, often mediation.
Mediation: For significant disputes, the Governance Agreement should require the co-owners to engage a neutral third-party mediator before any party can pursue legal remedies. Mediation is faster and cheaper than litigation and resolves most practical disputes without destroying the co-ownership relationship.
Disagreement about urgency: If one co-owner believes a repair is urgent and others disagree, the Governance Agreement should give the managing co-owner the authority to commission an independent licensed inspection. The inspector's determination of urgency then drives the decision, taking the debate out of the realm of personal opinion.
A co-owner who consistently refuses to approve legitimate repairs, blocks the reserve fund from being used for its intended purpose, or engages in willful neglect of shared maintenance obligations may be in breach of the Governance Agreement. The agreement should define what constitutes a breach and what remedies are available.
Emergency Repairs: Authority and Cost Handling
Some repairs cannot wait for a vote. A burst pipe, a gas leak, a structural failure, or a roof collapse in a storm requires immediate action. The Governance Agreement must address this scenario explicitly.
Emergency Authorization: Any single co-owner should have the authority to authorize emergency repairs when there is an immediate risk to the safety of occupants, a risk of catastrophic property damage, or a legal obligation to act (such as a municipal code violation). The definition of "emergency" should be written into the Governance Agreement to prevent abuse of this authority.
Spending Limit: Even in an emergency, a spending cap is reasonable. Emergency authorization might cover repairs up to a defined amount, say $10,000, with any cost exceeding that requiring retroactive group ratification within a defined period (often 72 hours or five business days).
Cost Recovery: Emergency repair costs are paid from the repair reserve. If the reserve is insufficient, co-owners contribute their proportional share within a defined timeframe, typically 30 days. The Governance Agreement should specify what happens if a co-owner fails to contribute their share of an emergency repair cost, including whether interest accrues on the unpaid amount.
Documentation: The co-owner who authorizes an emergency repair is responsible for documenting the situation: photographs of the damage, the vendor hired, the invoice, and a summary of the decision. This documentation protects all parties and supports any homeowner's insurance claim.
Insurance Claims: Co-owners should maintain a homeowner's insurance policy on the property. Emergency repairs that are covered by the policy should be submitted as claims. The Governance Agreement should designate who is responsible for filing and managing insurance claims and how any proceeds are applied.
How Rhome's Platform and Governance Agreement Handle These Situations
Rhome structures every co-ownership through an ownership structure with a comprehensive Governance Agreement that addresses maintenance, repairs, and capital improvements from the outset. You do not have to build these provisions from scratch or negotiate them in the middle of a repair crisis.
The Rhome Governance Agreement includes:
- Defined cost thresholds for routine maintenance, ordinary repairs, and capital improvements, calibrated to the specific property
- A repair reserve with defined contribution amounts, target balances, and withdrawal rules written into the agreement
- Decision-making protocols including vote thresholds by dollar amount and improvement type
- Emergency authorization provisions with documentation requirements and cost recovery timelines
- Dispute resolution procedures including mandatory mediation before litigation
- Vendor standards requiring licensed and insured contractors for above-threshold work
Beyond the legal structure, Rhome's platform gives co-owners a shared workspace for property management. Co-owners can log maintenance requests, track repair history, document vendor contacts, and communicate about upcoming decisions in a shared environment that keeps everyone on the same page. This operational layer sits on top of the legal framework and reduces the friction of day-to-day coordination.
If a repair comes up and you are unsure whether it meets the threshold for a group vote, the Governance Agreement answers that question. If a co-owner believes an improvement is urgent and others are not convinced, the documented inspection process provides an objective path forward. The structure does the work so the relationship does not have to carry all the weight.
Learn more about how Rhome works and what the platform includes from day one.
Frequently Asked Questions
See the FAQ section below for common questions about co-ownership repairs and maintenance.



