rhome
How It WorksPricingFor AgentsAbout
Back to Learning Center
Legal & Structure

What Is the Legal Structure Behind Co-Ownership?

When two to four people buy a home together, the legal structure they choose determines how decisions get made, how ownership transfers, and what happens if something goes wrong. This guide breaks down every major option and explains why LLC-based co-ownership has become the preferred framework for primary-residence co-buyers.

Rhome Editorial
9 min read
Need Legal Clarity
What Is the Legal Structure Behind Co-Ownership?

When two to four people buy a home together, the legal structure they choose shapes nearly everything: how title is held, how decisions get made, what happens when one person wants out, and what liability each person carries. Choosing the wrong structure does not just create paperwork problems later. It can make it genuinely difficult to sell, refinance, or resolve a dispute without expensive litigation.

There are three main legal frameworks used for co-owned residential property: tenancy in common, joint tenancy, and LLC-based co-ownership. Each has distinct characteristics, and the right choice depends on the buyers' goals, their relationship, and how they plan to use the property. For people purchasing a primary residence together with structured co-ownership, the LLC model offers the clearest governance, the cleanest path to exit, and the strongest protections.

This article walks through each structure in detail, explains how Rhome uses an LLC with a custom Governance Agreement, and gives you a practical framework for deciding what fits your situation.

Ownership of real property in the United States is defined by how title is held. Title determines who has legal ownership rights, how those rights can be transferred, and what happens to a co-owner's interest when they die or want to sell.

For co-buyers, there are three primary options:

  • Tenancy in common (TIC): Each owner holds a defined, separate share of the property. Shares can be equal or unequal. Each share can be sold, mortgaged, or transferred independently.
  • Joint tenancy: Owners hold equal, undivided shares. The defining feature is the right of survivorship: when one owner dies, their interest passes automatically to the surviving owners, bypassing probate.
  • LLC-based co-ownership: The LLC holds title to the property. Co-owners hold membership interests in the LLC rather than a direct ownership stake in the real estate. Governance is defined by an Operating Agreement.

A fourth option, tenancy by the entirety, exists in roughly half of U.S. states but is limited to married couples. It functions similarly to joint tenancy but with stronger creditor protections. It is not a practical option for unrelated co-buyers.

Each of the three main structures carries meaningfully different legal consequences.

Tenancy in Common: The Default, and Its Limits

Tenancy in common is the most widely used structure for co-owned property, largely because it is the legal default in most states when multiple buyers purchase property together without specifying another arrangement. If you and a co-buyer close on a home without explicitly selecting a structure, you are almost certainly holding title as tenants in common.

Under a TIC arrangement, each co-owner holds a distinct, undivided interest in the entire property. "Undivided" means no owner has exclusive control over any specific part of the home. Everyone has equal rights to use the whole property, regardless of ownership percentage. One owner can hold 60%, another 25%, another 15%, and all three still have full access to every room.

What TIC gets right:

TIC is flexible on ownership percentages. If co-buyers are contributing different amounts to the down payment or purchase price, those contributions can be reflected directly in the ownership split. This makes TIC administratively simple for situations where co-owners want their financial contributions to map cleanly to their ownership stake.

TIC interests are also independently transferable. Each owner can sell, gift, or bequeath their share without consent from the other owners (unless a co-ownership agreement says otherwise). This can feel like a feature, but it quickly becomes a liability in practice.

Where TIC falls short:

Because each TIC interest is independently transferable, a co-owner's creditors can potentially attach to and force a sale of that interest. If one co-owner faces a lawsuit, a divorce, or a bankruptcy, their TIC share can be exposed to claims by their creditors or their ex-spouse, even if you have done nothing wrong.

More critically, any co-owner in a TIC can petition the court for a "partition action" at any time. A partition action is a legal proceeding that forces the sale or physical division of the property. Courts generally favor partition by sale for residential property, which means one unhappy co-owner can compel a sale of the entire home, even if the other co-owners want to stay. There is typically no need to prove wrongdoing. The right to partition is a default legal right of any tenant in common.

Finally, TIC does not create any governance structure on its own. How do co-owners make decisions about repairs? What happens if one person stops paying their share of the mortgage? TIC is silent on all of this. Buyers who rely on TIC without a detailed co-ownership agreement are operating without a rulebook.

State variation note: Rules governing partition actions differ by state. Some states have adopted versions of the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act, which adds procedural protections. California, for example, has specific rules for TIC arrangements involving separate financing. Consult an attorney in your state for specific partition law.

Joint Tenancy: Survivorship and Its Trade-Offs

Joint tenancy is less common than TIC for co-buyers who are not spouses, but it appears frequently enough that co-buyers should understand it clearly before ruling it out.

The defining feature of joint tenancy is the right of survivorship. When one joint tenant dies, their interest does not pass through their estate or will. It passes automatically and immediately to the surviving joint tenants, in equal shares. This characteristic is appealing to some co-buyers because it avoids probate on the real property, which can be time-consuming and costly.

What joint tenancy requires:

For joint tenancy to be valid, courts traditionally require what are called the "four unities": time (all owners acquire their interest at the same moment), title (all from the same deed), interest (all hold equal shares), and possession (all have equal rights to possess the property). If these unities are not met at formation, the arrangement defaults to tenancy in common. Many states have relaxed these requirements, but equal ownership percentages are still typically required.

Where joint tenancy creates problems for co-buyers:

The equal-shares requirement is the first significant constraint. If co-buyers are contributing unequal amounts to the purchase, joint tenancy does not accommodate that. Every joint tenant holds exactly the same percentage, regardless of financial contribution.

The right of survivorship, while sometimes desirable, can also cut against a co-buyer's estate planning intentions. If you want your interest to pass to your own heirs rather than your co-owners, joint tenancy is the wrong structure.

Joint tenancy also does not solve the governance problem. Like TIC, it creates no rules for decision-making, cost-sharing, or exit. And joint tenancy can be severed by one owner without the others' knowledge in most states, converting it to TIC, which reintroduces all of TIC's vulnerabilities.

State variation note: Joint tenancy rules vary significantly. Some states require specific language on the deed to create joint tenancy. Others, like California, have a separate "community property with right of survivorship" option for married couples. Alaska has modified survivorship rules. Always verify with local counsel.

LLC-Based Co-Ownership: The Preferred Structure for Serious Co-Buyers

For co-buyers purchasing a primary residence with the intent to live together and build equity over time, LLC-based co-ownership offers significant structural advantages over TIC or joint tenancy.

The core mechanic is straightforward: instead of individual buyers taking title to the property in their own names, a limited liability company holds title. Each buyer owns a membership interest in the LLC, not a direct interest in the real estate. The LLC is the property owner of record.

This single structural choice opens up a set of legal and governance benefits that TIC and joint tenancy simply cannot replicate.

Liability protection:

An LLC is a separate legal entity. In most states, this means that a lawsuit against one member does not automatically expose the LLC's assets, which include the home, to that member's individual creditors. Similarly, if the LLC itself faces a claim related to the property, members' personal assets are generally protected (subject to proper LLC formation and maintenance requirements).

This protection is not absolute. Courts can "pierce the corporate veil" if the LLC is not properly maintained, if members commingle personal and LLC funds, or if the LLC was formed fraudulently. The protection is meaningful only when the LLC is treated as a real, separate entity with its own accounts and documentation.

State variation note: LLC liability protection rules vary by state. California, for example, charges an $800 annual minimum franchise tax on LLCs, plus potential gross receipts fees. Texas, Nevada, Wyoming, and Delaware are often cited as favorable LLC states, though this matters more for where the LLC is formed than where the property is located. Consult counsel about your specific state's LLC statutes.

No partition right by default:

Members of an LLC do not have the same automatic partition rights that tenants in common do. One member cannot simply petition a court to force the sale of the LLC's property without going through the process defined in the Operating Agreement and applicable LLC law. This is a meaningful protection that TIC cannot offer.

Clean, defined transfers:

When a co-owner in an LLC wants to exit, they transfer their LLC membership interest rather than conveying a deed interest in the real property itself. The Operating Agreement can and should define exactly how that transfer works: first right of refusal for existing members, valuation methodology, required notices, and permitted transferees. This structure makes exits predictable and private, without requiring a deed transfer and the associated recording, title work, and potential transfer taxes on the underlying real estate.

A container for governance:

The LLC's Operating Agreement is where the rules live. It can address every scenario that TIC and joint tenancy leave to chance: how monthly costs are divided, how maintenance decisions are made, what happens when one member cannot pay, how disputes are resolved, and what the exit process looks like. The Operating Agreement is a privately negotiated contract, enforceable under the LLC law of the state where the LLC was formed.

How Rhome Uses an LLC with a Governance Agreement

Rhome structures every co-ownership arrangement as a purpose-built LLC that holds title to the home. Co-buyers hold membership interests in the LLC, proportional to their ownership stake. The ownership split reflects each buyer's financial contribution and is defined in the LLC's Governance Agreement before closing.

The Governance Agreement is drafted to address the full lifecycle of co-ownership, not just the purchase.

Ownership and contributions: The agreement defines each member's ownership percentage, their share of the monthly mortgage payment, property taxes, insurance, and the repair reserve. It specifies what happens when one member is late on a payment, including cure periods and remedies.

Decision-making: Routine maintenance decisions are handled by simple majority. Larger decisions, such as refinancing or capital improvements above a defined threshold, require unanimous consent or a supermajority. The Governance Agreement eliminates the ambiguity that kills co-ownership arrangements.

The repair reserve: Rhome requires co-owners to fund a shared repair reserve, held at the LLC level, to cover unexpected maintenance costs. This prevents disputes over who pays for a new water heater or a roof repair from becoming crises.

Exit paths: The Governance Agreement defines three exit scenarios clearly. First, a co-owner can sell their membership interest to an approved third party, subject to existing members' right of first refusal. Second, existing members can buy out the departing member at a valuation defined in the agreement. Third, the LLC can dissolve and the property can be sold, with proceeds distributed per ownership percentage.

FHA financing compatibility: Rhome's LLC structure is specifically designed to work with FHA financing, where each co-buyer is individually underwritten. The 3.5% total down payment is split proportionally among members, and each member's loan corresponds to their ownership share. This is one of the more technically complex aspects of the structure, and Rhome's process is built around making it work correctly.

For a detailed breakdown of what a co-ownership agreement should cover, see our guide to co-ownership agreements.

What the LLC Structure Actually Provides

It helps to think about what the LLC structure delivers in concrete terms, rather than in abstract legal concepts.

A single, clear owner of record: The LLC's name appears on title. This simplifies everything downstream, from insurance to utilities to permit applications. There is no ambiguity about who owns what.

A firewall between personal finances and property obligations: If one member has a tax lien, a judgment, or a bankruptcy filing, the LLC structure creates a layer of separation between that member's personal situation and the property itself. This is not a guarantee of protection, but it is a meaningful buffer that TIC and joint tenancy do not provide.

A framework that lenders and title companies understand: LLCs holding residential real property are not new. Title companies know how to insure them. Attorneys know how to draft Operating Agreements for them. When it comes time to sell or refinance, the process is well-understood.

A private governance document: The Governance Agreement is not a public record. Co-owners' financial arrangements, decision-making rules, and exit terms remain private. A deed held as TIC is a public record, but the specific terms of a co-owners' arrangement live in a private LLC document.

An exit path that does not require court intervention: When co-owners disagree under TIC, the nuclear option is a partition lawsuit. Under LLC co-ownership with a well-drafted Governance Agreement, the exit process is defined and private. Disputes go to mediation or arbitration per the agreement's terms, not to a judge.

How to Choose the Right Structure

Most co-buyers do not need to conduct an exhaustive legal analysis to arrive at the right answer. A short decision framework helps.

Choose tenancy in common if: You need a simple, immediate solution, your co-buyer relationship is informal, ownership stakes are straightforward, and you are prepared to supplement TIC with a detailed written co-ownership agreement. TIC without a written agreement is not a sound choice for primary-residence co-buyers.

Choose joint tenancy if: All co-buyers want equal ownership shares, survivorship is an explicit goal (for example, unmarried partners who want property to pass automatically between them), and the property is in a state where joint tenancy is well-supported and does not create unexpected tax consequences.

Choose an LLC if: Co-buyers want governance clarity from the beginning, ownership percentages may be unequal, liability protection is a priority, a structured exit process matters, or co-buyers anticipate any complexity in the relationship over time. For primary-residence co-ownership among unrelated buyers, this is almost always the right answer.

One factor that often surprises people: the LLC structure does not meaningfully complicate homestead exemption claims in most states, as long as the co-buyer is using the property as their primary residence and the exemption is claimed correctly. However, rules differ by state. California's Proposition 19, for example, affects property tax reassessment when ownership transfers, including transfers into or out of an LLC. Florida's homestead exemption has its own rules for LLC-held property. Always verify with local counsel before closing.

For a detailed comparison of TIC and LLC co-ownership, see our article on co-ownership vs. joint tenancy.

Co-ownership legal structures involve real property law, LLC formation law, contract law, and potentially estate planning and tax law. No single article can substitute for qualified legal counsel. Here is what to look for when choosing an attorney for a co-ownership transaction.

Real property experience in the relevant state: Property law is state-specific. An attorney who primarily practices in a different state, even if brilliant, may not know the specific rules that govern your purchase. Confirm the attorney is licensed in the state where the property is located.

LLC drafting experience: Not every real estate attorney regularly drafts operating agreements for residential co-ownership. Ask specifically about their experience with LLC-held residential real property and with co-buyer operating agreements. Generic LLC operating agreement templates are not sufficient for the complexity of a primary-residence co-ownership arrangement.

Familiarity with co-ownership exit mechanics: Ask the attorney how they handle partition rights, buy-sell provisions, and member exit scenarios. Their answer will tell you whether they think about co-ownership as a dynamic relationship over time or just a one-time closing document.

Independence for each buyer: Each co-buyer should ideally have independent legal counsel review the co-ownership agreement before signing. One attorney cannot ethically represent all parties in a transaction where their interests may diverge. At minimum, each buyer should have the opportunity to consult independently.

For more on how Rhome coordinates the legal side of a co-ownership transaction, see how Rhome works.

Frequently Asked Questions

See the FAQ section below for answers to the most common legal structure questions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does holding property in an LLC affect my ability to get a mortgage?

Yes, and this is one of the most important structural considerations for co-buyers. Most conventional lenders will not lend to an LLC for a primary residence purchase. Rhome's model is specifically designed around FHA financing, where each co-buyer is individually underwritten and holds their loan personally, even though the LLC holds title. The mechanics of how this works at closing require coordination between the lender, title company, and legal counsel. This is not a DIY arrangement.

Can one co-owner force a sale of the property?

Under tenancy in common, any co-owner can petition a court for a partition action, which can compel a sale. Under an LLC structure with a well-drafted Governance Agreement, that right is replaced by the contractual exit process defined in the agreement. One member cannot unilaterally force a sale; they must follow the buy-sell procedure in the agreement. This is one of the primary reasons LLC co-ownership is preferred over TIC for primary-residence co-buyers.

What happens to my ownership interest if I die?

Under tenancy in common, your interest passes through your estate according to your will or state intestacy laws. Under joint tenancy, it passes automatically to surviving co-owners via the right of survivorship. Under LLC co-ownership, your membership interest passes through your estate like any other personal property, unless the Governance Agreement specifies otherwise. Many co-ownership Governance Agreements include provisions addressing what happens to a deceased member's interest, including whether surviving members have a right of first refusal to purchase it before it transfers to heirs.

Do LLC co-owners qualify for homestead exemptions?

In many states, yes, but the rules vary. Some states allow LLC members who use the property as a primary residence to claim homestead exemptions. Others require direct individual ownership on the deed. California, Florida, and Texas each have specific rules that apply differently to LLC-held property. You should verify the homestead exemption rules in your state with a local attorney before closing, particularly if property tax savings are a significant factor in your decision.

Is a co-ownership agreement the same as an Operating Agreement?

Not exactly. A co-ownership agreement is a general term for any contract that governs co-owners' rights and responsibilities. An Operating Agreement is a specific legal document that governs how an LLC operates, including membership interests, decision-making rights, and exit procedures. For LLC-based co-ownership, the Operating Agreement (which Rhome calls the Governance Agreement) serves as the co-ownership agreement. For TIC arrangements, co-owners would draft a separate co-tenancy agreement or co-ownership agreement that sits alongside the title structure. The Operating Agreement is the more comprehensive and solid document.

What are the tax implications of holding a home in an LLC?

A single-member LLC is taxed as a disregarded entity by default. A multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership by default. In the partnership tax framework, each member reports their share of income, deductions, and gains on their personal tax return (via Schedule K-1). This means mortgage interest and property tax deductions flow through to individual members in proportion to their ownership stake. However, the specific treatment of deductions, capital gains exclusions on sale, and property tax reassessment rules all vary by state and situation. Consult a tax professional before forming an LLC for co-ownership purposes.