When two or more people decide to buy a home together, the conversation usually centers on the property itself: the neighborhood, the price, the mortgage. The ownership structure question often comes up last, sometimes only at the title company the day before closing. That is exactly the wrong order.
How you hold title to a shared property shapes almost everything that follows. It determines what happens when one co-owner wants to sell. It affects whether a lender can hold one person liable for the full mortgage. It governs what happens if a co-owner passes away, goes through a divorce, or files for bankruptcy. Getting the structure right from the start is far easier than trying to fix it afterward.
There are three main paths co-buyers can take: direct ownership through tenancy in common or joint tenancy, a revocable living trust, or a limited liability company (LLC). Each has real advantages and real costs. None is universally correct, but for most groups of unrelated co-buyers, one structure tends to fit better than the others.
Option 1: Direct Ownership: Tenancy in Common and Joint Tenancy
Direct ownership means the co-buyers hold title personally, with their names on the deed. There are two primary ways to do this.
Tenancy in common (TIC) is the default structure in most states when two or more unrelated people buy property together. Each owner holds a defined percentage interest in the property. Those percentages do not have to be equal. One person can own 60 percent, another 40 percent, or any other combination the parties agree on. Each owner can sell, gift, or bequeath their interest independently. When a TIC owner dies, their share passes through their estate according to their will or state intestacy laws, not automatically to the other co-owner.
Joint tenancy includes a right of survivorship: when one co-owner dies, their share passes automatically and immediately to the surviving co-owners, bypassing probate. Joint tenancy requires equal ownership shares, which limits flexibility. It is most commonly used by married couples, though it is available to any co-buyers.
Where direct ownership works well
Direct ownership is the simplest path to get onto paper. There are no formation documents, no annual filings, no separate entity to maintain. If you and a sibling are buying a primary residence together with equal contributions and you both plan to live there long term, tenancy in common with a well-drafted co-ownership agreement can be perfectly adequate.
Direct ownership is also the most mortgage-friendly structure. Most conventional lenders, FHA programs, and VA programs require borrowers to hold title personally. If even one co-owner wants to use an FHA loan, which allows down payments as low as 3.5 percent for qualifying buyers, the title will need to be in individual names at closing.
Where direct ownership creates problems
The flexibility of TIC cuts both ways. Because each owner can sell or transfer their interest independently, one co-owner can force a partition action in court if they want out and the others will not buy them out. A partition lawsuit asks the court to either divide the property (rarely practical for a single home) or order a sale. The process is slow, costly, and can force an outcome no one wanted.
Direct ownership also provides no liability insulation. If someone is injured on the property and files a lawsuit, they can pursue the personal assets of every co-owner. There is no entity standing between the claim and a co-owner's bank account or other holdings.
For groups of three or more unrelated people, or any group where the owners have meaningfully different financial situations, different exit timelines, or different levels of involvement in the property, direct ownership without a robust legal agreement is an under-built structure for the complexity of what you are actually managing.
Option 2: Revocable Living Trust
A revocable living trust is a legal arrangement in which a trustee holds property for the benefit of named beneficiaries. The person who creates the trust (the grantor) can typically also serve as trustee during their lifetime, retaining full control. The trust becomes irrevocable at death, at which point the successor trustee takes over and distributes or manages assets according to the trust document.
Trusts are primarily an estate planning tool. For a single owner or a married couple, placing a home in a living trust is a clean way to avoid probate, maintain privacy, and streamline the transfer of the property at death. Many estate planning attorneys recommend it as a default for homeowners with meaningful assets.
Where trusts work well for co-buyers
If two co-buyers are a long-term couple who have already created estate plans together, holding the property in a shared revocable trust can make sense. The trust document can specify what happens to the property at the death of either party, avoiding the probate process entirely.
Trusts are also effective when a co-buyer wants to ensure their share of the property passes to a specific person, such as a child from a prior relationship, rather than defaulting to survivorship rules or a will that may be contested.
Where trusts fall short for co-buyer groups
Revocable living trusts are designed around individuals and families, not around groups of unrelated co-owners with different interests and exit timelines. They do not offer liability protection: because the trust is revocable, the grantor is treated as the beneficial owner for most legal and tax purposes, which means creditors can still reach the property.
More practically, a trust does not provide the governance framework that co-buying groups actually need. It does not define how decisions get made when co-owners disagree. It does not establish a process for one owner to sell their share to the other. It does not address what happens if one owner stops contributing to the mortgage or property expenses. These are exactly the situations that create conflict.
For groups of three or more unrelated co-buyers, or even two people with meaningfully different financial circumstances and timelines, a trust is rarely the right primary structure.
A note on FHA and trust title
FHA guidelines do allow title to be held in an inter vivos (living) trust under certain conditions. The borrower must be both the trustee and the beneficiary, must retain the right to occupy the property, and the trust must be revocable. The requirements are specific and lenders interpret them differently, so if FHA financing is part of your plan, confirm trust eligibility with your specific lender before assuming it will work.
Option 3: LLC: The Structure Built for Co-Ownership
A limited liability company is a legal entity that can own property. The co-buyers become members of the LLC. The LLC holds title to the home. Each member owns a percentage of the LLC rather than a direct interest in the real estate itself.
This structure is more work to set up and maintain than the alternatives, and it has real costs. But for groups of unrelated co-buyers, it addresses problems the other structures leave open.
Liability protection
Because the LLC is its own legal person, it provides a layer of separation between the property and the personal assets of each co-owner. If a guest is injured on the property and files a claim, the lawsuit is against the LLC. Each member's personal financial exposure is generally limited to what they have invested in the entity, not their personal savings or other assets. This protection is meaningful and is one of the primary reasons attorneys recommend LLCs for property held by a group.
It is worth noting that liability protection from an LLC is not absolute. Courts can "pierce the corporate veil" if the LLC is not properly maintained, if members commingle personal and LLC funds, or if the entity was set up specifically to evade an existing liability. Maintaining the LLC properly means keeping separate accounts, making decisions as an entity, and filing required state reports.
The Operating Agreement is the governance document
The LLC's Operating Agreement is where the real work happens. A well-drafted Operating Agreement for a co-buying group should address:
- Ownership percentages and how they were calculated
- Decision-making rules: which decisions require unanimous consent, which require a majority, and which one manager can make unilaterally
- Financial contributions: how the mortgage, taxes, insurance, and maintenance costs are split
- Buyout provisions: what happens when one owner wants to sell their membership interest, including how the property will be valued and how long the remaining members have to exercise a right of first refusal
- Default provisions: what happens if one member stops paying their share
- Exit timelines: whether the group has agreed to a target hold period before considering a sale
- Death, divorce, and disability: what happens to a membership interest in those scenarios
This level of specificity is what co-ownership groups actually need. The Operating Agreement turns a general intention to share a property into a set of written rules that everyone agreed to before problems arose. When something goes wrong, and over a multi-year co-ownership arrangement something eventually will, the Operating Agreement is what prevents a dispute from becoming a lawsuit.
Tax treatment
A single-member LLC is a disregarded entity for federal tax purposes. A multi-member LLC is treated as a partnership by default. In both cases, the LLC itself does not pay federal income tax. Income, deductions, and credits pass through to the members proportionally, who report them on their individual returns. Members can generally still deduct their proportionate share of mortgage interest and property taxes, subject to standard IRS limitations.
State tax treatment varies. Some states impose an annual LLC franchise tax or minimum fee regardless of whether the entity is profitable. California, for example, charges an $800 annual minimum franchise tax on LLCs. Other states have lower fees or none at all. Factor state-specific costs into the decision.
What the LLC does not solve: mortgage financing
This is the most important practical constraint. Most residential mortgage lenders, including all FHA and VA programs and most conventional lenders, will not lend directly to an LLC. They lend to individuals.
This means most co-buying groups using an LLC need to take one of two paths. The most common approach is to obtain the mortgage in individual names, close on the property personally, and then immediately transfer title from the individuals to the LLC by recording a deed. Many attorneys refer to this as a "title to LLC" transfer post-closing.
Be aware of two things when doing this. First, most mortgages contain a due-on-sale clause that technically allows the lender to call the loan due when title is transferred. In practice, lenders rarely exercise this clause on a transfer to a single-purpose LLC owned by the same borrowers, but you should discuss this with your attorney and, if possible, notify or confirm with your lender. Second, the transfer may trigger a reassessment of property value for local tax purposes in some jurisdictions, which could affect your property tax bill. California's Proposition 19 and similar rules in other states deserve careful attention here.
The alternative is commercial financing or portfolio lending, which is available through some local banks and credit unions that hold loans on their own books rather than selling them to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. These lenders can sometimes lend directly to the LLC, but the terms, rates, and qualifying criteria are typically less favorable than conventional residential mortgages.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Tenancy in Common | Living Trust | LLC | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability protection | None | None (revocable) | Yes (if maintained) |
| Governance document | Co-ownership agreement | Trust document | Operating Agreement |
| Probate avoidance | No | Yes | Partial (members' interests) |
| FHA financing | Yes | Conditional | No (direct) |
| Conventional financing | Yes | Yes | Generally no |
| Unequal ownership | Yes | Complex | Yes |
| Forced partition risk | Yes | No | No |
| State annual fees | None | None | Varies (often $50 to $800+) |
| Setup complexity | Low | Medium | Medium to High |
| Best for | Couples, simple pairs | Estate planning | Groups of 2+ unrelated buyers |
Which Structure Fits Unrelated Co-Buyers Best
For two or more unrelated adults buying a home together, especially when they have different financial profiles, different long-term plans, and want a clear process for handling exits and disagreements, an LLC with a strong Operating Agreement is the structure most attorneys recommend.
The liability protection is real. The governance framework is necessary. The ability to define exit processes in advance prevents the most common co-ownership disputes from becoming expensive legal fights.
The main tradeoff is the mortgage constraint. If FHA financing is essential, such as when one or more buyers needs a low down payment option, the group will likely need to hold title personally at least through closing, then work with an attorney to transfer to an LLC afterward. This requires planning and some upfront legal cost, but it is a solved problem that real estate attorneys handle regularly.
If you are a couple buying together and you have an existing estate plan, a living trust may already be the right home for the property and creating a separate LLC may be unnecessary overhead. If you are two siblings buying a vacation cabin with equal contributions and very low conflict potential, a well-drafted TIC agreement might genuinely be enough.
But if you are three friends buying together, or two colleagues with different incomes and different ideas about how long to hold the property, the LLC's built-in structure is worth the setup cost.
When to Talk to a Real Estate Attorney
The ownership structure decision should happen before you make an offer, not after. Here is when you especially need legal advice:
Before signing a purchase agreement, confirm which structure you are using. If you are planning to transfer title to an LLC post-closing, your attorney can advise on timing, the due-on-sale clause risk, and any state-specific tax implications.
When drafting the Operating Agreement, do not use a generic template. The buyout provisions, default triggers, and decision-making rules in a co-buyer Operating Agreement are specific to your situation. An attorney who understands real estate and entity law in your state will catch problems that a boilerplate document misses.
If any co-buyer is using FHA financing, confirm the structure with the lender and have an attorney review the post-closing transfer plan before you commit to it.
Any time state law matters, and it always does. LLC laws, property transfer taxes, homestead exemptions, and partnership taxation rules vary significantly by state. An attorney licensed in the state where the property is located is the right person to advise on local specifics. A general answer from the internet, including this article, is a starting point, not a substitute for that advice.
Rhome's platform includes resources and partner connections to help co-buying groups find attorneys experienced with these structures. You can start by exploring how co-ownership works on Rhome.
FAQ
Note: FAQ content is in the faqItems field below.



