rhome
How It WorksPricingFor AgentsAbout
Back to Learning Center
Legal & Structure

What Landmark Designation Means for a Co-Owned Home

Buying into a landmark-designated property comes with genuine privileges and real constraints. Before you co-buy, you need to understand what local landmark status actually controls, how it shapes every exterior decision you and your co-owners will make, and how your Governance Agreement should account for it.

Rhome Editorial
7 min read
Need Legal Clarity
What Landmark Designation Means for a Co-Owned Home

What Landmark Designation Means for a Co-Owned Home

Some of the most compelling homes in any city carry a landmark designation. They are the 1890s brownstone with original slate window surrounds, the Craftsman bungalow whose porch columns have never been altered, the mid-century flat-roof house that looks like it stepped out of a Julius Shulman photograph. They are architecturally significant, often deeply beautiful, and frequently priced below comparable non-landmark homes because buyers recognize the extra layer of oversight that comes with them.

For co-buyers, that extra layer matters in ways that go beyond what a solo owner faces. When two, three, or four people share a home, every exterior decision becomes a group decision. Add landmark approval requirements on top of that, and you have a coordination challenge that demands thoughtful planning before you sign anything.

This article explains what landmark designation actually is, what it controls, how it affects the co-ownership dynamic, and how to prepare your legal structure for it.

What Landmark Designation Is

A landmark designation is a formal legal status granted to an individual building, structure, interior space, or object by a local government authority, typically a city or county landmarks commission or preservation board. The designation recognizes that the property has special historical, cultural, architectural, or aesthetic significance to the community.

The key word is individual. A landmark is a single building or site, not a zone or neighborhood. That is the distinction most buyers miss.

A historic district is a geographically defined area where many properties, sometimes hundreds or thousands of them, are collectively recognized for their contribution to neighborhood character. Being inside a historic district subjects your property to design review, but the rules typically apply to the neighborhood pattern as a whole.

A landmark designation applies to your specific building. It means your property has been singled out as architecturally or historically significant on its own. The standards of review are often stricter, the attention from the preservation commission is more focused, and the restrictions can be more specific to the particular features that made your building noteworthy in the first place.

Some properties carry both designations simultaneously: a building may be a contributing structure within a historic district and an individually designated city landmark. In that case, the more restrictive rules generally govern.

National Register of Historic Places listing is a separate federal designation that does not impose local restrictions on private owners, but it does reach federal tax credits for qualifying rehabilitation work. Local landmark designation, by contrast, comes with enforceable local restrictions regardless of whether the property also has federal recognition.

How Landmark Status Is Designated

Local landmark designation follows a process set by each municipality. The details vary by city, but the general structure is consistent across most jurisdictions.

Any qualified party, which may include the property owner, a preservation organization, a city council member, or in some cities any interested citizen, can initiate a nomination. The nomination documents why the property meets the local criteria for significance, which typically include architectural quality, historical associations, cultural importance, or the work of a notable architect or craftsperson.

A landmarks commission or preservation board then reviews the nomination in a public hearing. Owners have the right to participate in that process, and in many jurisdictions, owner consent is required before designation can proceed (though some cities allow designation over an owner's objection in cases of exceptional public significance).

If the nomination is approved, the designation is recorded and becomes part of the property's public record. It runs with the land, meaning it transfers to every future owner. When you buy a landmark property, you are taking on the obligations that come with that designation, and those obligations belong to every co-owner jointly.

What Landmark Status Restricts

Landmark designation regulates what you can change about the property's significant features, most commonly its exterior appearance. The core principle in preservation law is reversibility: changes should preserve the historic fabric of the building, and ideally any alteration should be capable of being undone without damaging original material.

In practical terms, that means the following categories of work typically require review and approval from the local landmarks commission before you can proceed:

Exterior alterations. Replacing windows, changing door profiles, adding or removing architectural ornament, repainting with a color that deviates from an approved palette, reroofing with a materially different product, adding signage, or installing mechanical equipment visible from a public way.

Additions. Building a rear addition, expanding a footprint, adding a deck or pergola visible from the street, or modifying a garage or ancillary structure.

Demolition. Full or partial demolition is generally prohibited unless the commission finds extraordinary hardship. Even removing a deteriorated secondary structure may require approval.

Routine maintenance that uses substitute materials. Replacing original clapboards with fiber cement, swapping wood windows for vinyl, or painting over unpainted masonry may seem like routine upkeep but can constitute a material change under preservation standards.

Work that is entirely interior and does not affect significant exterior features generally does not require landmarks commission approval, though some designations extend to interior spaces of exceptional significance (grand hall interiors, original fireplaces, decorative tile, and the like).

The governing document is the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA), the permit issued by the landmarks commission authorizing a specific change. No building permit for regulated work can be issued until the COA is in hand.

How Landmark Status Affects Co-Owner Decisions

For a solo owner, landmark requirements add steps to a project timeline. For co-owners, they add steps to a decision-making process that already has more participants.

Every time your co-ownership group wants to do something that requires landmarks commission review, you need to get the group aligned on the scope of the project, agree on who coordinates the application, share the cost of any design or architectural documentation the commission requires, and then wait through the review calendar (which in busy cities can run six to twelve weeks for a full hearing).

This is not inherently a problem, but it needs to be anticipated. Co-owners who have not thought through the landmark layer sometimes discover it mid-renovation when a contractor pulls permits and hits an approval wall. At that point, you have a partially disassembled house, a stalled project, and a co-ownership group that may disagree about next steps.

The practical implications break into a few categories:

Repair standards are higher. When original materials fail, the commission will generally prefer like-for-like replacement: wood window sashes replaced with wood, original brick tuckpointed rather than parged, slate roofing replaced with slate or an approved equivalent. Like-for-like materials often cost more than modern substitutes. Co-owners need to budget for this premium and agree in advance that they will meet the preservation standard rather than defaulting to the cheapest available option.

Timelines are longer. A decision to add solar panels, replace windows, or change the paint color can take months if it requires a public hearing. Projects that one co-owner wants done quickly may be delayed regardless of the group's consensus.

Documentation requirements can be substantial. The commission may require architectural drawings, material samples, or historical photographs to evaluate a proposal. Those cost money, and that money needs to come from somewhere in the co-ownership structure.

Unapproved work can be forced to be undone. If one co-owner commissions exterior work without going through the COA process, the city can require restoration of the original condition at the owner's expense. In a co-ownership, that cost lands on all owners. Clear authority rules in your Governance Agreement are essential.

Tax Benefits of Landmark Status

Landmark designation is not only restrictive. In many jurisdictions, it comes with meaningful financial benefits that can offset the higher cost of preservation-standard repairs.

Local property tax abatements or freezes. Many cities offer landmark owners a freeze or reduction in the assessed value of the property for a period of years following designation or following qualifying rehabilitation work. The specifics vary considerably by municipality, so you should confirm what is available in the city where the property is located.

State historic tax credits. A number of states have their own historic rehabilitation tax credit programs that apply to individually designated landmarks, not just federally listed properties. These credits typically apply to substantial rehabilitation projects and can offset a meaningful portion of the qualified rehabilitation expenditures.

Federal Historic Tax Credit. For properties that are also listed on or eligible for the National Register of Historic Places, a 20% federal tax credit is available for certified rehabilitation of income-producing property. A primary residence used exclusively as a home does not qualify for the federal credit, but if the co-owned property has any income-producing component, the credit may be worth exploring with a tax advisor.

Grant programs. Some municipalities and preservation nonprofits offer matching grants or low-interest loans for exterior restoration work on designated landmarks. These programs are often underutilized because owners do not know they exist.

The tax benefits and grant opportunities are real, but they are not automatic. They require applications, qualifying work plans, and in many cases review by the same commission that oversees your COA applications. Building those processes into your renovation planning from the beginning saves time and captures money that would otherwise be left on the table.

How the Governance Agreement Should Address Landmark Requirements

The Governance Agreement (sometimes called the Co-Ownership Agreement or Governance Agreement, depending on how you have structured your purchase) is the contract that governs how you and your co-owners make decisions about the property. For any co-owned home, it needs to cover decision-making, expense allocation, dispute resolution, and exit rights. For a landmark property, it also needs to address the layer of external regulatory authority that governs exterior changes.

Here is what a well-drafted Governance Agreement should cover for a landmark co-owned home:

Acknowledge the landmark status explicitly. The agreement should name the designating authority, the date of designation, and reference where the controlling regulations can be found. This establishes shared baseline knowledge and removes any later claim of surprise.

Require unanimous or supermajority consent for any COA application. Because a submitted application commits the group to a proposed scope of work and may result in conditions the commission imposes, all co-owners should have a meaningful vote before any application goes in.

Establish a preservation maintenance standard. The agreement should state affirmatively that all repairs and replacements to regulated features of the property will meet the preservation standard required by the landmarks commission, and that no co-owner may commission work that would require COA approval without group authorization.

Allocate COA-related costs. Architectural fees, design documentation, material premiums, and the cost of any required restoration should be defined as shared operating expenses.

Set a timeline expectation. Because landmark review adds weeks or months to any regulated project, the agreement should note that exterior project timelines are subject to commission calendars, and no co-owner can hold another co-owner in breach for delays caused by the regulatory review process.

Address emergency repairs. Sometimes a significant weather event or sudden failure creates urgency that cannot wait for a commission hearing. Many jurisdictions have emergency COA procedures for exactly this scenario, but your agreement should also address what authority any individual co-owner has to initiate emergency stabilization work pending full approval.

Questions to Ask Before Buying a Landmark Property

Before you and your co-buyers commit to purchasing a landmark-designated home, get clear answers to each of the following:

What specific features are protected? Ask the landmarks commission for the designation report, which describes the significant features of the building. Knowing whether the commission cares about the roof form, the original windows, the historic outbuilding, or the interior staircase tells you what your future project constraints will actually look like.

What projects were previously approved, and what were the conditions? Past COAs are usually public records. Reviewing them tells you how the commission has treated this property historically and whether there are ongoing conditions attached to earlier approvals.

Are there any open violations or unapproved alterations? Prior owners may have done exterior work without going through the commission. If unapproved alterations exist, the commission could require remediation after you take title. A title search and a pre-purchase consultation with a preservation attorney can surface this risk.

What grant and tax benefit programs apply? Call the local preservation office and ask specifically what financial incentive programs are available to landmark property owners in that jurisdiction. Get it in writing.

How long does COA review typically take for a project of the scale you anticipate? If you are planning significant exterior work in the first year, you need to understand the commission's meeting calendar and typical review timelines before you build your renovation plan.

Does the designation extend to any interior spaces? Most designations do not, but some do. Confirm the scope before you finalize your renovation plans.

FAQ

Note: See faqItems below for FAQ content.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does landmark designation affect the interior of the home?

Most local landmark designations focus on exterior features and do not restrict interior renovations. However, some designations extend to interiors of exceptional architectural significance, such as original grand staircases, decorative tile work, or historic fireplaces. The designation report for your specific property will spell out exactly which features are protected. Always request and read that document before purchasing.

Can co-owners lose the landmark designation if they want to?

Landmark designations are generally very difficult to remove. De-designation requires a formal petition to the same landmarks commission that granted the status, and the bar for approval is high. In most cities, an owner who wants to de-designate must demonstrate that the property no longer meets the criteria for significance or that designation causes exceptional hardship. For most buyers, it is safer to assume that landmark status is permanent and plan accordingly.

Who is legally responsible if one co-owner does unpermitted exterior work on a landmark?

The city's enforcement action will typically run against all property owners, not just the individual who commissioned the work. Fines, stop-work orders, and mandatory restoration requirements can fall on the entire co-ownership. This is precisely why your Governance Agreement needs clear rules about authority to commission exterior work, and why no co-owner should engage a contractor for regulated exterior work without full group authorization.

Do landmark restrictions apply to temporary changes, like holiday decorations or seasonal plantings?

Temporary, non-destructive changes such as holiday lighting, container plantings, or removable decorations generally do not require Commission of Appropriateness approval because they do not alter the permanent fabric of the building. However, any modification that involves attachment to historic materials, even something as minor as mounting a bracket into original masonry, may technically require review. When in doubt, call the local landmarks office and confirm before drilling or attaching anything.

Does a landmark property qualify for special financing or insurance treatment?

Most conventional lenders treat landmark-designated properties like any other residential property for mortgage purposes. Some lenders in certain markets may require inspection confirmation that the property is in good repair per preservation standards. For insurance, historic properties sometimes require specialty coverage that reflects the higher cost of like-for-like material replacement. It is worth comparing quotes from insurers who specialize in historic homes alongside standard homeowners policies to find the right fit.