rhome
How It WorksPricingFor AgentsAbout
Back to Learning Center
Comparisons

Co-Ownership Legal Structure vs Tenancy in Common

Tenancy in common and LLC-based co-ownership are both legitimate ways to share a home, but they differ significantly in how decisions get made, how exits work, and what happens when co-owners disagree. Understanding those differences before you sign anything can save years of conflict.

Rhome Editorial
9 min read
Need Legal Clarity
Co-Ownership Legal Structure vs Tenancy in Common

Tenancy in common (TIC) and LLC-based co-ownership both let multiple people
own a home together. The core difference is governance: a TIC gives you a
deed and proportional ownership rights, but no built-in rules for how
co-owners make decisions, fund repairs, or exit gracefully. An LLC wraps the
same ownership interest in a legal entity with an Operating Agreement that
spells out exactly those rules. Neither structure is inherently superior in
every case. What matters is whether the structure matches the complexity of
your situation.

What Is Tenancy in Common?

Tenancy in common is a form of concurrent real estate ownership in which two
or more people each hold an undivided interest in the same property. Each
owner's share is recorded on the deed. The shares do not have to be equal:
one owner might hold 60% while another holds 40%.

A few defining characteristics set TIC apart from other co-ownership forms:

No right of survivorship. When a TIC owner dies, their share passes
through their estate, not automatically to the other owners. This is the
opposite of joint tenancy, where a deceased owner's share transfers directly
to the survivors.

Independent transferability. A TIC owner can generally sell, gift, or
mortgage their own share without the consent of the other owners, subject to
any separately drafted agreements. This flexibility can be an asset or a
liability depending on your relationship with your co-owners.

Undivided interest. No owner has exclusive rights to a specific bedroom
or square footage. Every owner has proportional rights to use the whole
property. Physical division of use is handled by private agreement, not by
the deed itself.

TIC is the default ownership structure in most U.S. states when two or more
unmarried people buy a property together without specifying a different
form. Some states, including California and Texas, have their own default
rules and presumptions, so always confirm with a licensed attorney in your
state.

What Is LLC-Based Structured Co-Ownership?

In an LLC-based co-ownership arrangement, the property is titled in the name
of a limited liability company rather than in the names of the individual
owners. Each co-owner holds membership interest in the LLC, not a direct
deed interest in the property.

The LLC is governed by an Operating Agreement, a private contract among the
members that defines everything the deed does not:

  • Decision-making thresholds. What vote percentage is required for major

repairs, refinancing, or sale? The Operating Agreement answers this.

  • Expense allocation. How are mortgage payments, property taxes,

insurance, and maintenance split? The agreement sets default percentages and
override mechanisms.

  • Exit mechanics. What happens when one co-owner wants to sell? The

agreement typically includes a right of first refusal, a buyout formula, and
a timeline to prevent indefinite deadlock.

  • Repair reserves. How much cash must each owner contribute to a shared

maintenance fund?

  • Default consequences. What occurs if one member stops paying their

share of the mortgage or expenses?

The Operating Agreement is where the real governance lives. The LLC entity
itself is the vehicle that makes that governance legally binding on all
members.

For a deeper look at how the legal framework of co-ownership is constructed,
see our guide on [co-ownership legal
structure](/learn/co-ownership-legal-structure).

Key Differences: A Structural Comparison

Governance and Decision-Making

A bare TIC has no built-in governance mechanism. If you and a co-owner
disagree about whether to replace the roof or refinance the mortgage, there
is no default tiebreaker. You either negotiate to an agreement or pursue
litigation. Courts are generally reluctant to manage ongoing property
disputes between co-owners, so unresolved disagreements tend to end in a
partition action (see below).

An LLC with a well-drafted Operating Agreement addresses governance
explicitly before disputes arise. Voting thresholds, veto rights, and
tie-breaking procedures are written in. Co-owners know going in what the
rules are.

Partition Rights

This is the most significant structural vulnerability of bare TIC. Under
U.S. property law, any TIC owner can petition a court to force a partition
of the property at virtually any time. The court can order either a
partition in kind (physical division of the land, rarely practical for a
single-family home) or a partition by sale (the property is sold at auction
and the proceeds divided proportionally).

A forced partition sale typically occurs at below-market value because the
timeline is court-driven and the property may be sold as-is. Co-owners who
wanted to keep the property have little recourse once a court orders a
partition by sale.

Within an LLC, members do not have partition rights in the same sense. A
member cannot unilaterally force a sale of the underlying real estate by
petitioning for partition; they can only seek to exit their LLC membership
interest. The Operating Agreement controls what that exit looks like, which
typically means a buyout or a right-of-first-refusal period before the
interest can be transferred outside the group.

Transfer Rights

In a TIC, an owner can transfer their undivided interest to a third party
without the other owners' consent unless a separate agreement restricts
this. That means a stranger could theoretically become your co-owner if your
partner sells their share.

An LLC Operating Agreement routinely includes transfer restrictions. Members
typically cannot sell or transfer their membership interest without approval
from the other members or must offer the interest to existing members first
(right of first refusal). This keeps the co-ownership group intact and
protects existing members from unwanted new partners.

Liability

In a TIC, each owner holds title directly. If a judgment creditor obtains a
lien against one owner's personal assets, that lien can potentially attach
to their TIC interest and affect the property. The other owners may face
complications when they try to sell or refinance.

An LLC provides a liability shield. A creditor of an individual member
generally cannot reach the LLC's assets (the property itself) directly; they
can only pursue the member's economic interest in the LLC, subject to state
charging-order protections. The property is insulated from the personal
liabilities of any individual member, though this protection has limits and
varies by state.

Estate Planning

TIC's lack of survivorship rights makes it more flexible for individual
estate planning: each owner can leave their share to whomever they choose
through a will or trust. However, this means a deceased co-owner's heirs
(who may be strangers to the arrangement) automatically become TIC co-owners
unless the Operating Agreement or a separate agreement addresses this.

An LLC Operating Agreement can specify exactly what happens to a member's
interest upon death: whether it transfers to their estate, whether the LLC
has the right to buy it back at a set formula, or whether the heirs can
become members only with existing member approval. This gives all parties
more predictability.

The Biggest Risk With Bare TIC: No Exit Agreement

The partition lawsuit risk gets most of the attention, but the deeper
problem with bare TIC is the absence of a pre-negotiated exit mechanism.
When co-owners are enthusiastic and aligned, the lack of a written agreement
feels fine. When circumstances change, that absence becomes critical.

Consider a realistic scenario: two friends buy a home together as TIC
owners. Three years later, one wants to sell to move across the country. The
other wants to stay. Without an agreed buyout formula, they have to
negotiate the price from scratch while the relationship is already strained.
If they cannot agree, the departing owner's options are limited: they can
try to sell their undivided TIC interest on the open market (a difficult
sale, since most buyers do not want to share a home with a stranger), or
they can file for partition.

A partition by sale forces both owners out, typically at a loss relative to
a negotiated private sale, and the legal fees compound the financial damage.
This outcome is not rare. It is the default endpoint when co-owners have no
exit agreement and reach a genuine impasse.

Adding a co-ownership agreement on top of a TIC can address this. A
well-drafted co-tenancy agreement can restrict transfer rights, establish
buyout formulas, and limit partition rights contractually. But drafting and
enforcing such agreements adds cost and complexity, and some courts have
historically been reluctant to enforce contractual restrictions on partition
rights, depending on the jurisdiction.

When TIC Makes Sense vs When an LLC Is Better

TIC may be appropriate when:

  • Two spouses or domestic partners are buying together and already have

estate planning documents in place that address the survivorship question

  • The co-owners are in a state with solid TIC regulations and have access

to attorneys who can draft a thorough co-tenancy agreement

  • The arrangement is short-term and the co-owners are highly aligned on exit

timing

  • The co-owners want direct deed ownership for mortgage underwriting

simplicity (some lenders are more comfortable with TIC than LLC)

LLC-based co-ownership is typically better when:

  • Multiple unrelated parties are buying together (two or more friends,

family members, or colleagues)

  • The co-owners have different financial situations, timelines, or risk

tolerances

  • Long-term ownership is the goal
  • Any party has personal liability concerns or creditors
  • A structured exit mechanism is important to any party
  • The co-owners want to avoid the partition lawsuit risk entirely

One important note on mortgages: some lenders will not provide conventional
residential financing directly to an LLC. This is a real practical
constraint. Buyers using LLC structures may need to purchase in their
personal names and transfer to an LLC after closing (which can trigger a
due-on-sale clause risk, depending on the loan) or use lenders who
specialize in this structure. This is a material consideration and worth
discussing with a mortgage professional before choosing your structure.

How Rhome's Structure Adds Governance to Co-Ownership

Rhome uses a structured ownership entity model for all co-ownership arrangements, with a
standardized governance agreement that covers the gaps that bare
TIC leaves open. Each co-owner holds an interest in a
property-specific ownership entity, and the governance agreement is drafted before closing
so all parties understand the rules before committing.

The key elements Rhome's structure addresses:

Repair reserve. Each member contributes to a shared maintenance fund on
an ongoing basis, so major repairs do not become a negotiation crisis.

Swap exit. Rhome offers a platform-facilitated exit mechanism where a
departing member's interest can be matched with a new buyer rather than
forcing an open-market sale or a partition. This replaces the most
adversarial part of TIC exits with a structured process.

Decision-making thresholds. The governance agreement specifies what
decisions require unanimity, a supermajority, or a simple majority, so
day-to-day management does not require consensus on everything.

Platform management. Rhome handles the administrative layer (expense
tracking, reserve contributions, dispute escalation protocol) so co-owners
are not left to manage the relationship entirely on their own.

This is not a fundamentally different ownership model from TIC in terms of
the underlying real property rights; it is the governance layer added on top
of the ownership structure that changes the co-owner experience. For a
comparison with other co-ownership arrangements, see [co-ownership vs joint
tenancy](/learn/co-ownership-vs-joint-tenancy) and [what is a managed
property trust](/learn/what-is-managed-property-trust).

For a full picture of how the Rhome platform works day to day, see [how
Rhome works](/how-it-works).

Comparison Table

FeatureBare TICLLC-Based Co-Ownership
Ownership formDirect deed interestLLC membership interest
GovernanceNone by defaultOperating Agreement

| Partition right | Yes, any owner can force sale | No direct partition
right |
| Transfer restrictions | None by default | Typically restricted by
agreement |

| Liability shield | No | Yes (subject to state law) |

| Survivorship | No (passes through estate) | Controlled by Operating
Agreement |
| Exit mechanism | Negotiation or partition | Buyout formula / right of
first refusal |

Repair reserveNo default requirementSet by Operating Agreement
Mortgage accessStraightforwardMay require specialized lenders
Setup costLowerHigher (legal fees, entity formation)

FAQ

See faqItems below.

---

*This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal
or financial advice. Co-ownership structures vary by state. Consult a
licensed attorney in your jurisdiction before structuring any real estate
transaction.*

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you convert a tenancy in common into an LLC structure after purchase?

Yes, but it requires a deed transfer from the individual owners to the LLC, which can trigger documentary transfer taxes and, if the property has a mortgage, a potential due-on-sale clause. Some lenders will waive the due-on-sale clause for transfers into a revocable living trust or a closely held LLC, but this is not guaranteed. You should work with a real estate attorney and your lender before making the transfer.

Is a tenancy in common agreement legally binding?

A co-tenancy agreement (a contract layered on top of a TIC) is generally enforceable as a private contract between the parties. However, courts in some states have historically been reluctant to enforce contractual restrictions on a co-owner's right to seek partition, treating partition as a fundamental property right. This is one reason why the LLC structure, which eliminates the partition right at the property level, offers stronger protection than a TIC agreement alone.

What happens to a TIC interest when one co-owner dies?

Unlike joint tenancy, a TIC interest does not pass automatically to the surviving co-owners. It transfers through the deceased owner's estate, which means probate if there is no trust or beneficiary designation in place. The heirs who inherit the TIC share become co-owners of the property, even if the remaining owners did not choose them as partners. An LLC Operating Agreement can address this by giving the LLC or remaining members the right to buy out an inherited interest before it transfers.

Does an LLC protect co-owners from each other's debts?

An LLC provides a structural separation between personal debts and the property. A creditor of one member typically cannot force a sale of the LLC's real estate to satisfy a personal judgment; instead, they pursue a charging order against that member's economic interest in the LLC. The strength of this protection varies significantly by state. California, for example, provides limited charging-order protection for single-member LLCs but stronger protection for multi-member LLCs. Consult an attorney in your state for specific guidance.

Do all co-ownership platforms use LLC structures?

No. Some co-ownership arrangements still use bare TIC, particularly in markets where TIC has a long history, such as San Francisco. Others use managed property trusts, limited partnerships, or other vehicles. The legal structure matters less than the quality of the governance documents layered on top of it. An LLC with a poorly drafted Operating Agreement offers little practical advantage over a TIC with a thorough co-tenancy agreement. The key is having explicit, enforceable rules before co-owners need them.