Most groups of young professionals face this question at some point, usually
when a lease is ending or rent just went up again: should we keep renting
together, or is it time to buy? The answer is not the same for every group.
It depends on how long you plan to stay, how stable your finances are, and
how committed the group is to a shared long-term plan. What the numbers
consistently show is that buying together builds substantially more wealth
over five years. What the numbers cannot tell you is whether your group is
actually ready to make that commitment.
Financial Comparison: 3 Years and 5 Years
Let's model a specific scenario. Three friends in a mid-tier city are
deciding between signing another lease on a three-bedroom apartment or
buying a home together.
Rental scenario:
Three-bedroom apartment: $3,300 per month total. Per person: $1,100.
Utilities and renter's insurance add roughly $125 each per month. Monthly
housing cost per person: $1,225.
At 4% annual rent increases:
- Year 1: $14,700 per person
- Year 2: $15,288
- Year 3: $15,900
- 3-year total per person: $45,888
- Year 4: $16,536
- Year 5: $17,197
- 5-year total per person: $79,621
Equity at the end of year 3: $0. Equity at the end of year 5: $0.
Co-buying scenario:
Three friends purchase a $465,000 home together using FHA financing.
Down payment (3.5%): $16,275 total, or $5,425 each.
Closing costs per person: approximately $4,500.
Total upfront per person: $9,925.
Monthly PITI (principal, interest, taxes, insurance, HOA if applicable):
approximately $3,480 total, or $1,160 per person.
Repair reserve contribution: approximately $50 per person per month
(standard practice for co-owned property).
Effective monthly housing cost per person: $1,210. Essentially identical to
renting, within noise.
After 3 years:
Home value (3.5% annual appreciation): approximately $516,000.
Mortgage paydown: approximately $15,600 total, or $5,200 per person.
Appreciation gain: $51,000 total, or $17,000 per person.
Total equity per person after 3 years: $5,425 (initial) + $5,200 (paydown) +
$17,000 (appreciation) = approximately $27,625.
Total cash out per person after 3 years: $9,925 upfront + ($1,210 x 36) =
$53,485.
After 5 years:
Home value: approximately $552,000.
Mortgage paydown: approximately $28,000 total, or $9,333 per person.
Appreciation gain: $87,000 total, or $29,000 per person.
Total equity per person after 5 years: $5,425 + $9,333 + $29,000 =
approximately $43,758.
Total cash out per person after 5 years: $9,925 upfront + ($1,210 x 60) =
$82,525.
Head-to-head:
| Renting (per person) | Co-Buying (per person) | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost (year 1) | $1,225 | $1,210 |
| Total cash out at 3 years | $45,888 | $53,485 |
| Equity at 3 years | $0 | ~$27,625 |
| Net position at 3 years | -$45,888 | -$25,860 |
| Total cash out at 5 years | $79,621 | $82,525 |
| Equity at 5 years | $0 | ~$43,758 |
| Net position at 5 years | -$79,621 | -$38,767 |
At three years, the co-buyers have spent a bit more total but are $20,000
ahead on net financial position. At five years, the spending is nearly equal
but the co-buyers hold $43,758 in equity that the renters do not. The gap
only widens from there.
The Non-Financial Factors
Numbers are only part of the decision. Everything below is relevant to
whether your group should actually consider buying.
Commitment: Buying is a long-term commitment. Signing a lease is a
one-year commitment with easy renewal. A home purchase involves closing
costs, mortgage obligations, and a Governance Agreement. If one person in
your group is not ready to commit to three to five years in the same city,
that person should not be in the co-buying group, at least not yet.
Flexibility: Renting wins on flexibility. If someone gets an unexpected
opportunity in another city, they give notice and go. A co-buyer who wants
to exit needs to follow the process defined in the Governance Agreement,
which takes more time and coordination. Exit paths exist through Rhome's
structure, but they are not the same as breaking a lease.
Legal complexity: Renting together requires no legal paperwork beyond
each person's name on the lease. Co-buying requires an ownership structure, a Governance
Agreement, and individual mortgage underwriting. The legal structure is what
protects everyone, but it does add a layer of process that renting does not.
Relationships: Homeownership with friends changes the relationship.
Financial entanglement at this level is a real thing. It can strengthen
relationships built on trust and communication, or it can create friction in
relationships where those qualities are absent. This is worth examining
honestly before committing.
Control over the property: Co-buyers can paint, renovate, adopt a pet,
and make decisions about their home that renters cannot. Landlord permission
is not required. This is a meaningful quality-of-life difference that
renters rarely fully account for until they have experienced ownership.
When Renting With Friends Makes More Sense
- Your group has one or more people with genuine uncertainty about their
city or timeline within the next two to three years
- One or more potential co-buyers cannot meet the income, credit, or
first-time buyer requirements for FHA financing
- The group has not lived together before and does not have a tested track
record of handling shared finances
- Rent in your city is low relative to home prices, making the buy-rent
financial ratio unfavorable
- The group has not had a serious conversation about the legal and financial
commitment involved, and is not ready to
When Buying With Friends Makes More Sense
- All potential co-buyers are planning to stay in the city for at least four
to five years
- Each person meets the qualification requirements independently (income,
credit, first-time buyer status)
- The group has a history of clear communication about money and has
navigated shared financial decisions before
- You are paying rent that is competitive with what co-ownership would cost
on a monthly basis
- Everyone has read and understood what the Governance Agreement actually
covers
- The group is ready to own and maintain a property together, including the
unglamorous parts (repairs, shared reserve fund, decisions about the water
heater)
How to Have the Conversation With Your Friends
The biggest barrier to co-buying among friend groups is not financial. It is
the awkwardness of bringing up a serious financial commitment in a social
relationship.
A few practical suggestions:
Start with a specific threshold. Ask everyone: are you planning to stay
in this city for at least four years? That single question filters out the
co-buying candidates from the people for whom renting is the right answer
right now.
Talk about money early. Share actual numbers, credit score ranges,
income levels, and current savings. This conversation is uncomfortable but
essential. Surprises discovered after you are under contract are worse.
Treat it like a business decision. The Governance Agreement is a business
document. Approach the discussion the same way you would approach a business
partnership, with clear roles, clear expectations, and no assumptions.
Give everyone an honest out. Not everyone in your friend group is
necessarily the right co-buying partner, even if the friendship is strong. A
good co-buying conversation makes it easy for people to opt out without
social penalty.
Get qualified first. Before anyone commits emotionally to the idea, find
out whether each person actually qualifies. Rhome can walk you through the
pre-qualification process. If someone does not qualify, the conversation
takes a different shape, and that is better to know early.
FAQ
See faqItems below.

